Published by EPIC, the European Policy Innovation Council →

Poland Moves to Strip Its Constitutional Court Chief of Immunity

Icon
6 min read
Icon
News & Analysis
Icon
Nov 18, 2026
News Main Image
The seat of Poland's Constitutional Tribunal in Warsaw, where judges met on 17 November to decide on lifting the court president's immunity. © Jurij, CC BY-SA 3.0 via Wikimedia Commons.
  • Judges at Poland's Constitutional Tribunal met on Tuesday to decide whether to lift the immunity of the court's own president, Bogdan Święczkowski, and his deputy Bartłomiej Sochański. Prosecutors want consent to detain and arrest Święczkowski. The ruling is due to be made public on Wednesday 18 November.
  • Six judges appointed under the former Law and Justice government call the meeting unlawful. The central bank has frozen payments from the Tribunal's accounts because it is no longer clear who runs the court.
  • The fight now reaches the Sejm, Europe's human rights court and disciplinary panels meeting on 19 and 20 November. Ten years after the crisis began, Poland's Constitutional Tribunal has split in two.

Poland's Constitutional Tribunal spent Tuesday trying to decide whether its own president should be arrested. A General Assembly of judges, called by the court's longest-serving member, Anna Korwin-Piotrowska, considered a stack of requests from Prosecutor General Waldemar Żurek to strip Bogdan Święczkowski and his deputy Bartłomiej Sochański of immunity. Some of the requests go further and ask for consent to detain and arrest Święczkowski. The Tribunal said its decision would be made public on Wednesday, 18 November. If immunity is lifted, a sitting president of the court could face arrest for the first time in the country's history.

Święczkowski, standing outside the building on Tuesday morning, called the people running it "usurpers" and told reporters he had packed a bag in case he was detained. He did not attend the hearing.

How the court split in two

The Tribunal has 15 judges. For most of the past decade it was dominated by appointees of the Law and Justice (PiS) government, starting with the contested selections of 2015 that set off the EU's long rule-of-law dispute with Warsaw. That majority has now flipped. Five judges elected by the current Sejm, and three more sworn in before the president, together make up a majority.

On 30 October Korwin-Piotrowska, acting as the most senior judge, suspended Święczkowski as president and Sochański as vice-president for a month. On 3 November the new majority ruled that the General Assembly needs eight judges, not ten, to pass resolutions. It left out the two suspended men and Jarosław Wyrembak, whom it treats as an irregularly appointed "duplicate" judge. Legal scholars and the Helsinki Foundation for Human Rights have questioned whether the rules she relied on apply to the Tribunal at all.

The other side does not accept any of it. Six judges, among them Święczkowski, Sochański, Wyrembak and former PiS prosecutor-politician Stanisław Piotrowicz, signed a statement saying they "firmly oppose the unlawful attempt to lift the immunities". They argue the assembly was called by someone with no authority to call it, included judges who are not serving and had no quorum, so nothing it decides has legal effect.

What the prosecutors allege

Żurek, who is both justice minister and prosecutor general, has sent the Tribunal case files running to 50 volumes. Most of the allegations go back to Święczkowski's years as national prosecutor from 2016 to 2022, under PiS. They include unlawful use of surveillance material and disclosure of classified information in the Pegasus spyware investigation, improper secondment of prosecutors, and abuse of power over the prosecution service's purchase of the Hermes system. Both men also face allegations that, as the court's leaders, they stopped other Tribunal judges from doing their jobs and breached their employment rights.

Święczkowski tried to get help from Strasbourg and failed. A seven-judge panel of the European Court of Human Rights unanimously refused his and Sochański's request for an interim measure, finding no imminent risk of irreparable harm. Government officials were quick to point out the irony: a court president who had ignored Strasbourg's interim measures in the past was now asking it for protection.

Money, Parliament and the President

The dispute has already spread beyond the courtroom. Narodowy Bank Polski, the central bank, has frozen all payments from the Tribunal's accounts, saying it can no longer tell who has authority to sign them. President Karol Nawrocki calls the new leadership an unconstitutional takeover. Prime Minister Donald Tusk is backing the new judges.

On Tuesday the fight reached the Sejm. MPs rejected a constructive vote of no confidence from the right-wing Rozwój Plus group, which would have replaced Tusk with veteran conservative Marek Jurek. Former prime minister Mateusz Morawiecki said the government had broken "all the rules of the rule of law" in the Tribunal conflict. Tusk dismissed the motion as a "rather pathetic grotesque".

The next round comes quickly. Disciplinary panels at the Tribunal are due to rule on 19 and 20 November on the suspensions and the prosecutors' charges. Święczkowski's lawyer has written to the police, prosecutors and security services warning that arresting him without valid consent would be a serious crime.

Why Brussels is watching

Poland's rule-of-law dispute with the EU began at this court. In the 2021 Xero Flor ruling, the European Court of Human Rights found that a Tribunal bench including an irregularly appointed judge was not a "tribunal established by law". The Commission went on to take Poland to the EU Court of Justice over the Tribunal's rulings against the primacy of EU law. The Tusk government won back billions in frozen EU funds by promising to repair the judiciary. Its critics now accuse it of using emergency methods to do so.

What This Means

Poland is trying to undo a captured court with tools that its own opponents, and some neutral lawyers, call irregular. The result is a Constitutional Tribunal with two rival leaderships, two sets of judges who each say the other is illegitimate, and a central bank refusing to pay the court's bills until someone works out who is in charge. Wednesday's announcement on Święczkowski's immunity will not settle that. If the new majority consents to his arrest, PiS and the president will call it a political prosecution. If it does not, the government's repair project stalls. Either way, Brussels faces a test of its own principle: a court must be independent, and it must also be lawfully constituted. Right now Poland's highest constitutional body is struggling to be either.

EU Insider
EU Insider Newsroom