Published by EPIC, the European Policy Innovation Council →

EU Inc Is Being Negotiated Into Something Nobody Asked For

Icon
4 min read
Icon
Business & Economy
Icon
Nov 19, 2026
News Main Image
EU flags outside the Berlaymont in Brussels, headquarters of the European Commission, whose EU Inc proposal is being cut back by member states. Photo by Christian Lue on Unsplash.
  • EU Inc, the Commission's plan for a single EU-wide company form, is being stripped back in negotiations. Governments removed the entire insolvency chapter when they agreed their position on 23 October.
  • Three leading business-law scholars now say the Commission should withdraw the text. The ECB's Isabel Schnabel has warned that a watered-down version would be "another lost opportunity".
  • MEPs are split over how the new company form should interact with national rules on worker board seats, and a deal by the end of 2026 looks increasingly unlikely.

The EU's flagship answer to Delaware is in trouble. When the European Commission proposed its "28th regime" this spring, the pitch was simple: one legal form for companies anywhere in the bloc, digital incorporation for €100, and a fast, simple way to wind up a start-up that fails. Eight months on, the version being negotiated looks very different.

On 23 October EU governments agreed their negotiating position and cut the chapter on insolvency entirely. That chapter was meant to give Europe something it has never had: a cheap, predictable way to fail and start again, the kind of "culture of failure" that underpins American venture capital. Capitals have also given the proposal a lukewarm reception more generally, worried about losing control over company law at home.

The case for pulling it

Three business-law scholars argue the project is now worse than nothing. In a joint article titled "Brussels should withdraw EU Inc before it goes off", Luca Enriques of Bocconi University, Casimiro A. Nigro of the University of Leeds and Tobias H. Tröger of Goethe University Frankfurt and the Leibniz Institute for Financial Research write that "what is being negotiated under its name is something else. The Commission should acknowledge as much and withdraw the text." Their worry is that a half-harmonised regime, full of national carve-outs, would create legal uncertainty rather than remove it.

The European Central Bank shares the concern. In a speech in Vilnius on 13 November, Isabel Schnabel, the ECB board member who leaves in January, said that if the proposal is "watered down, for example by leaving room for national gold-plating or limiting harmonisation in the area of insolvency," it "would risk becoming another lost opportunity." She wants the regime set out in a directly applicable EU regulation, open to firms of any size or age.

Parliament's own fault line

The European Parliament has its own problem. Political groups are divided over how EU Inc should interact with national laws on employee participation, the German-style rules that give workers seats on company boards. Unions fear the new form becomes a way round them; business groups fear the opposite. With that unresolved, a deal by the end of 2026 is looking increasingly unlikely, even though EU Inc is meant to be the centrepiece of the Commission's "One Europe, One Market" roadmap.

Why business is losing patience

The fight lands as companies grow openly frustrated with the gap between Brussels' competitiveness rhetoric and delivery. More than two years after Mario Draghi's report, Europe still struggles to turn an estimated €10 trillion in retail savings into risk capital. "We have growth capital, we have seed capital, we don't have risk capital," Jacob Bossaer, founder of Belgian water-tech firm BOSAQ, told the European Business Summit in Brussels this week. Booking.com chief executive Glenn Fogel went further, saying the Commission seemed to be "running out of letters" for the acronyms of new laws and challenging it to publish a running list of what it has actually simplified.

What This Means

EU Inc was supposed to prove that the EU could deliver something founders actually want. Instead it is becoming a textbook case of how ambition gets negotiated away: capitals guard their company law, MEPs fight over board seats, and the one feature that would most change behaviour, simple insolvency, goes first. The Commission now faces a real choice. It can accept a weak regime and claim a win, or fight for the original text and risk running out of time. If the scholars and the ECB are right, the worst outcome is the middle one: a 28th regime that adds a 28th set of complications.

EU Insider
EU Insider Newsroom